Mood-related issues like anxiety and depression are super-common among women on the pill. Almost half of all women who go on the pill stop using it within the first year because of intolerable side effects, and the one most frequently cited is unpleasant changes in mood. Sometimes it’s intolerable anxiety; other times, it’s intolerable depression; or maybe both simultaneously. And even though some women’s doctors may tell them that those mood changes aren’t real or important, a growing body of research suggests otherwise.

… according to the research, you might have a greater risk of experiencing negative mood effects on the pill if:

  • You have a history of depression or mental illness (although there is also evidence that the pill can stabilize mood in certain women with mental illness).
  • You have a personal or family history of mood-related side effects on the birth control pill.
  • You are taking progestin-only pills.
  • You are using a non-oral product.
  • You are taking multi-phasic pills (pills with an increasing dose of hormones across the cycle rather than a constant dose).
  • You are 19 or younger.
Underlying causes:

» irregular ovulation
» Hypothalamic-pituiatary-ovarian axis disturbance
» vitamin and mineral deficiencies
» dysbiosis

Are you having problems coming off the pill?

The medical approach to period problems shuts ovulation with contraceptives such as the Pill, implants, injections and Nuvaring.

As ovulation stops, so the production of DHEA, oestrogen, progesterone shuts down as well. It causes the ovaries to shrink by almost 50%, to the same size that they shrink to at menopause. When HBC is discontinued, the ovaries previously suppressed with synthetic hormones fail to return to healthy function, often leading to irregular periods, heavy bleeding and acne.

In the meantime the hormonal imbalances cause troubling and potentially serious side effects such as depression, weight gain, microbiome disturbance, and loss of libido.

Emerging research is also suggesting long term impacts on insulin resistance, fat mass, diabetes and bone mass.

What is hormonal birth control?

Our natural hormones oestrogen, progesterone an DHEA are required to make a healthy brain, bones, muscles and metabolism.

  • Estradiol (the main oestrogen) plays a key role in insulin signalling;
  • Estradiol and progesterone influence the release of neurotransmitters – serotonin, dopamine, GABA – to keep your mood stable throughout the cycle;
  • Progesterone converts to alloprogesterone and interacts with the brain and nervous system to relax and keep your mood stable coming up to your period.

The steroids in HBC are not the same as our natural hormones.

  • Natural oestrogen is replaced by Ethinyl estradiol which worsens insulin sensitivity, causing insulin resistance and weight gain.
  • Natural progesterone is replaced with a variety of progestins
  • Levonorgestrel causes abortions – it is used in the Plan B abortion pill
  • Many synthetic progestins have a similar structure to testosterone, and are androgens i.e. they work as testosterone
  • Natural progesterone is a calming hormone which converts to allopregnenalone, which is a strong modulator of the GABA receptors in the brain. It is hormonal valium. Progestins don’t convert to allopregnenalone and so don’t support mood or brain function. Levonorgestrel dramatically reduces progesterone and therefore allopregnenalone, and does the opposite, reducing GABA receptors, leading to anxiety.

Synthetic Progestins increase testosterone

Progestins have an androgen index, indicating how close their effects are to testosterone. Androgenicity is described as the progestin’s affinity for and binding to the androgen receptor, and it’s effect on the sex hormone binding globulin (SHBG). SHBG binds testosterone and estrogen making the sex hormones unavailable for use at the receptors.

Levonorgestrel and dl-norgestrel have a high affinity for sex hormone binding globulin and decrease free sex hormone binding globulin levels by binding it and displacing testosterone, consequently increasing free testosterone levels. (PMID: 15802398)

High androgen index:

  • Causes acne, weight gain, anxiety and hair loss (can be devastating)
  • Older progestins are made from testosterone
  • Progestins include: Levonorgestrel, Norgestrel, Medroxyprogesterone
  • Included in: Levelen, emergency contraception, Mirena, Depo-provera

Medium androgen index:

  • Norethindrone, Desogesterel, Etonogestrel
  • Included in: Loestrin, Implanon, Nova ring

Low androgen index:

  • suppress DHEA, higher risk of fatal blood clots, depression and anxiety, loss of libido
  • Drospirenone – derived from a diuretic drug – anti-androgen – reduces acne but causes more depression, anxiety and clot risk than the high androgen progestins
  • Cyprotenone – Yaz and Yasmin, Brenda

Mirena coil

  • It is an intrauterine Levonorgestrel releasing IUD
  • Works locally in the uterus, prevents fertile mucus, impairs sperm and thins the uterine lining.
  • Blood levels of progestins are at 10% compared to Levonorgestrel pill, but this is still enough to cause androgen side-effects in some women such as acne and hair loss.
  • Allows normal estradiol and some ovulation .

Side effects of taking HBC

  • Altered microbiome of gut
  • Altered microbiome of vagina
  • Altered brain structure
  • Altered sleep architecture
  • Reduced bone density
  • Gallbladder disease
  • Increased risk of cervical dysplasia
  • Increased risk of autoimmune disease
  • Zinc deficiency
  • 3-fold higher risk of breast cancer
  • Digestive bloating
  • Recurrent bladder infections
  • Thrush
  • Vaginal dryness

Side effects of stopping HBC

A real period is about the healthy functioning of the ovaries and the healthy production of oestradiol and progesterone via ovulation. A pill bleed suppresses those hormones and instead is a bleed from the withdrawal of the drugs. So the timing of the pill bleed is about the dosing of the drug.

There is no medical reason to bleed monthly on HBC. Hence HBC does not regulate periods. It stops periods altogether, and a bleed only occurs when HBC is paused which causes a drug deficiency.

Once HBC is stopped, the most common symptoms are:

  • Irregular or skipped periods
  • Heavy menstrual bleeding
  • Ovulation pain and menstrual cramps
  • Acne breakouts
  • Bloating
  • Mood swings

My approach to coming off HBC easily

I support women in coming off hormonal birth control to minimise unwanted side effects such as rebound acne, irregular periods or no periods. Additionally she provides support for weight loss and hair growth.

My approach is tailored to each woman. Hormonal birth control does not fix period problems, only masks them so support is customised depending on the health issues before starting hormonal birth control.

My approach to coming off the pill consists of consecutive stages, and ideally should begin 2-3 months before HBC is stopped:

  1. Address health issues masked by HBC:
    Individualised support, with 4 distinct strategies, depending on how periods were before HBC started:
    • PLAN A: normal periods
    • PLAN B: irregular periods
    • PLAN C: acne
    • PLAN D: heavy bleeding and/or period pain

  2. Support nutrition:
    • Individualised recommendations for appropriate nutrition, including avoiding sugar and dairy increasing healthy fats, protein, fibre and phytonutrients.
    • Full blood tests including: liver function, thyroid metabolism, iron levels, vitamin D, vitamin B12, folate, cholesterol, zinc levels.

  3. Recommend appropriate supplements
    Individualise supplementation of all the nutrients that HBC depletes including:
    • B vitamins: loss of B vitamins can lead to depression, which then leads women to be prescribed anti-depressant medication (if you would like support with coming off anti-depressants then please mention this at your discovery call).
    • Magnesium
    • Zinc
    • Vitamin D, which declines once off HBC, and is required for ovulation
    • Support the hypothalamic pituitary ovarian axis with glandulars to revive the ovaries, restore ovary-brain communication and support fertility.

  4. Test hormones periodically
    • 3 months after coming off HBC, testing for oestradiol, progesterone and testosterone is recommended, to make any further adjustments to your protocol.
    • Some women may need cortisol tests.

  5. Support you while your periods normalise and symptoms reverse

How long will it take for periods to resume and normalise?

How long it takes for periods to resume and normalise depends on which HBC was taken, how long it was taken for, what it was taken for originally and your age.

  • Stopping the Pill should allow the ovaries to return to their normal size within 3 months, and AMH levels to normalise within a year. Which means that conception can be delayed for over a year.
  • It can take up to 18 months for cycles to return after Depo-Provera discontinuation
  • IUD can allow a quick return of fertility, but progestin-based IUDs can take longer.

The wonderful news is that I can guide and support you with nutrition, supplements and lifestyle changes to restore ovarian function and get you back to your natural flow.

… a prospective, population-based, 2-year observational study of Canadian adolescents aged 16–19 years showed that those who used combined hormonal contraceptives (CHC) had decreased gains in femoral bone mineral density compared with those who did not use CHC. Loss of bone mineral density on CHC was unrelated to dose of ethinyl estradiol. Earlier data had already shown the lack of a dose effect from CHC estrogen on bone; patients on 20–35 ÎĽg ethinyl estradiol CHC formulations all had suppressed markers of bone remodelling. Our recent meta-analysis comparing adolescents who did and did not use CHC also showed impaired accrual of bone mineral density among CHC users across a wide range of doses.

Why might adolescents taking CHC have lower gains toward peak bone mineral density than those not taking CHC? Bone resorption and formation are tightly coupled physiologic processes. As with the lower doses of estrogen in menopausal hormone therapy, CHC suppress bone resorption and therefore prevent the necessary bone growth that adolescents require to reach peak bone mineral density.

A new study in Denmark, published in JAMA Psychiatry, investigates the effects of hormonal contraception on risk for developing depression and using antidepressant medication. The study was partially funded by the Lundbeck Foundation (Lundbeck is a pharmaceutical company that sells antidepressants). The results of the nationwide study, analyzing data from over one million women, suggest that hormonal contraceptive use may increase the risk of depression and use of antidepressants, especially for adolescents.

… The authors conclude, “Our data indicate that adolescent girls are more sensitive than older women to the influence of hormonal contraceptive use on the risk for first use of antidepressants or first diagnosis of depression.”

READ MORE

Contraceptive freedom made women in Britain richer, but the prescription rate is falling and even after decades its effects on the body are far from clear

It was one of the greatest medical and social advances of the 20th century, a quantum leap for women’s freedom. Sixty years ago today Britain’s young, married women were told that if they started taking a tiny pill every day they could be both sexually liberated and in complete control of their fertility.

….When we asked for your experiences we heard from women of all ages. For most, this form of contraception has had unparalleled benefits: a way to manage heavy periods, PMS or other painful conditions, a greater sense of control over one’s body and, of course, a way to prevent pregnancy.

Others had a different story to tell. They spoke of lowered sex drive, mood swings, depression and emotional numbness. The list of physical side effects was long: spots, bloating, weight gain, cramps, headaches, vertigo, tender breasts, hair loss.

Today the pill is still the most popular type of contraception for women in the UK, but prescription rates are falling. NHS data for England shows that in 2020-21 there was a 39 per cent uptake of the contraceptive pill, down from 45 per cent in six years. So what’s behind the decline? And 60 years on, how much do we really know about the pill?

…Hormonal birth control creates myriad problems for the thyroid, beginning with the depletion of vital nutrients such as magnesium, selenium, zinc, and essential B Vitamins, like folate. The thyroid needs these important nutrients, especially zinc and selenium, to convert T4 to T3. Unfortunately, no amount of supplements will help your body overcome this obstacle.

While depleting nutrients, birth control also elevates production of Thyroid Binding Globulin (TBG). This protein binds with thyroid hormones to carry them through the blood stream, but renders them unable to attach to cell receptors. Consequently, the body may try to compensate by overproducing T3 and T4, without actually increasing hormone activity. This could explain why some women develop Grave’s Disease after stopping The Pill. Their TBG levels return to normal, but their body continues overproducing T3 and T4.

…As the central organ in the metabolic process, the liver produces proteins, breaking down fat and hormones to generate energy. When we overload the body with an unnatural flood of factory-produced, artificial hormones, the liver becomes sluggish and inefficient. This sets off a toxic cascade of side effects that leads to inflammation, and could ultimately contribute to chronic illnesses such as heart disease, cancer, and autoimmune disease.

The National Institutes of Health were concerned about hormonal birth control’s affect of the endocrine system from the very early days. When Dr. Philip Corfman, the Director of the Center for Population Research, testified at the Nelson Pill Hearings in 1970 on behalf of the NIH, he warned that The Pill decreased the liver’s ability to change and dispose of certain chemicals, even decreasing its ability to excrete bile.

Millions of healthy women take a powerful medication every day from their mid-teens to menopause – the Pill – but few know how this drug works or the potential side effects. Contrary to cultural myth, the birth-control pill impacts on every organ and function of the body, and yet most women do not even think of it as a drug. Depression, anxiety, paranoia, rage, panic attacks – just a few of the effects of the Pill on half of the over 80% of women who pop these tablets during their lifetimes.

When the Pill was released, it was thought that women would not submit to taking a medication each day when they were not sick. Now the Pill is making women sick. However, there are a growing number of women looking for non-hormonal alternatives for preventing pregnancy.

In a bid to spark the backlash against hormonal contraceptives, this book asks: Why can’t we criticize the Pill?

Get notified about new editions

Subscribe to the Sunday Supplement

Connecting women, science and spirit, the Gynelogic Sunday Supplement delivers a bi-monthly dose of  news, views and reviews, as seen through my lady lens.