Abstract

Homocysteine is an intermediate substance formed during the breakdown of the amino acid methionine and may undergo remethylation to methionine or trans-sulfuration to cystathionine or cysteine. The metabolism occurs via two pathways: remethylation to methionine, which requires folate and vitamin B12; and transsulfuration to cystathionine, which requires pyridoxal-5’-phosphate.

The disturbances in the metabolic pathways lead to the accumulation of Hcy, either by insufficient transsulfuration (through CBS mutations or vitamin B6 deficiency) or by a blockage of remethylation. In the latter case, folate or vitamin B12 deficiency may be involved, as well as MTHFR.

High levels of Hcy induce sustained injury of arterial endothelial cells, proliferation of arterial smooth muscle cells and enhance activity of key participants in vascular inflammation, atherogenesis, and vulnerability of the established atherosclerotic plaque.

Hyperhomocysteinemia has become the topic of interest in recent years. It has been highly associated with increased risk for cardiovascular disorders, such as, atherosclerosis, thromboembolism and dyslipidemia.

Women with PCOS show constellation of metabolic syndromes. Obesity, hyperandrogenemia and type 2 diabetes mellitus is the hallmark of PCOS which later becomes the risk factors for cardiovascular disease. Various studies had revealed the presence of increased Hcy level in PCOS women which may or may not be associated with other biochemical parameters. Intense treatment for PCOS can influence homocysteine levels.

Introduction

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) proves as the most common endocrine disorder with a prevalence of 5% to 15% worldwide [1] , for the women of active reproductive age, but the prevalent rate varies depending on the criteria used for the diagnosis [2] [3] . According to the Rotterdam diagnostic criteria, the prevalence rate of PCOS accounts up to 18% of reproductive-aged women [2] [3] , whilst the prevalence rate is 10% when using NIH criteria for diagnosis criteria [3] but the prevalence is still unknown in children [2] [4] . Three different criteria have been implemented for the diagnosis of PCOS: the NIH criteria (1990), the Rotterdam criteria (2003) and the Androgen and PCOS society (AE-PCOS) criteria (2006) [5] [6] . Amongst the three criteria, the Rotterdam criterion was adopted as the Practice Guidelines of the Endocrine Society [2] [7] . The Rotterdam criteria comprise features as, chronic menstrual dysfunction, clinical or biochemical hyperandrogenism and polycystic ovaries confirmed by ultrasonography (≥10 follicles and ≥10 ml ovarian volume) [8] . The etiology of PCOS still remains unclear but various predisposing genes interfere with environmental and lifestyle manners [5] [9] , makes PCOS a complex genetic disorder. The constellations of symptoms significantly affect the quality of life of PCOS women and the syndrome is associated with an increased long term risk factors such as cardiovascular disease, diabetes mellitus, infertility, cancer and psychological disorders [10] .

In current years, homocysteine, a biosynthesis of methionine has proved as a major cardinal feature of PCOS. It is a non-protein a-amino acid and cysteine homologue. Its metabolic pathway encompasses either remethylation to methionine or through transsulfuration to cystathionine as shown in Figure 1 [11] . The first metabolism pathway requires folate and vitamin B12 whereas the latter requires pyridoxal-5’-phosphate. S-adenosylmethionine (SAM) augments the synthesis of both pathways which is a moderator of methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR) and inhibitor of cystathionine β-synthase (CBS). The metabolic pathways are interrupted by any impaired function either by insufficient transsulfuration through CBS mutation or deficiency of vitamin B6 or secondly by remethylation blockage, can lead to abnormal accumulation of plasma Hcy. In the latter case, the accumulation of homocysteine could be due to deficiency of folate or vitamin B12, as well as MTHFR [12] .

A condition that emerges from disrupted homocysteine metabolism is hyperhomocysteinemia which has been known as the most significant risk factor for cardiovascular disease and has been confirmed by recently conducted meta-analysis study by Homocysteine Studies Collaboration [13] . Deficiencies in cystathionine beta synthase, methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase or enzymes involving methyl-B12 synthesis, as a result of a rare genetic defect, lead to severe hyperhomocysteinemia. In fasting status, due to mild impairment in the methylation mechanism (i.e. folate or B12 deficiencies or MTHFR thermolability), occurs mild hyperhomocysteinemia [12] . Homocysteine play a role as a mediator for endothelial damage and dysfunction [14] that subsequently impairs endothelial vasoreactivity and decrease endothelium thromboresistance. Hence, hyperhomocysteinemia associated with increased risk of atherosclerosis, thromoboembolic diseases and hyperinsulinemia is verified which is directly proportionate to increased risk of cardiovascular disorders with a strong correlation to insulin resistance. Hyperhomocysteinemia also aggravates the incidence of late pregnancy complications, such as preeclampsia, abruption placentae, preterm birth and intrauterine fetal death [15] . Hyperhomocysteinemia is also one of the major factors that leads to early miscarriages by impairing by interfering endometrial blood flow and vascular integrity [16] and also described as the sole variable resulting in recurrent pregnancy loss [17] .

According to numerous clinical studies, PCOS in women is associated with existence of endothelial and platelet dysfunction, minimal chronic inflammation, increased coronary artery calcification and carotid intima-media thickness in PCOS women [18] . PCOS women are highly susceptible to both cardiovascular risk factors, such as, obesity dyslipidemia, hypertension and type-2 diabetes mellitus, and mood disorders, such as depression and anxiety [2] .

Influence on Hcy Level Post PCOS Therapy

Insulin and Hcy have the ability to induce each other by inhibiting hepatic CBS [23] that results in hyperhomocysteinemia leading to compensatory hyperinsulinemia by inducing insulin resistance. This may impair activity of the MTHFR or CBS enzymes, leading to abnormal deposition of homocysteine in plasma [24] [51] [52] . This explains that insulin resistance may be the most important marker of metabolic disease in PCOS women [53] . Hence, metformin has always been the mainstay treatment for PCOS women with insulin resistance. With administration of metformin, some study has shown beneficial decrease in plasma Hcy level [8] [54] . Nonetheless, it is also studied that metformin monotherapy is unsatisfactory [55] . The study conducted by Vrbrikova et al. revealed that the treatment with metformin only may increase the plasma Hcy level [56] . Administration with rosiglitazone and metformin seem to decrease elevated oxidative stress compared to metformin treatment but no significant changes were observed in plasma Hcy [40] . Kilicdag et al. also reported the same result [57] . This statement can be explained by folate depletion and malabsorption of vitamin B12 [58] [59] that disturbs Hcy metabolism, thus, supplementation with folate can be preventative [57] [60] . Moreover, treatment with metformin and cyclic medroxyprogesterone acetate (MPA) also tend to increase Hcy level [55] . Stefano Palombo et al. reported that treatment with metformin can slightly reduce the Hcy level in PCOS women, but supplementation with folate has shown to increase the beneficial effect [60] . Hence, folate supplementation is the first therapeutic measure advised in obese PCOS patients that prevents rise in Hcy level during weight loss. A prospective randomized clinical study in 2010, in both obese and non-obese PCOS women, observed dramatic decrease in plasma Hcy level when treated with metformin. However, the study in the both group when treated with oral contraceptives increased the plasma Hcy level and other biochemical parameters that increased the metabolic risk [61] .

Statins have also been administered and seems to deplete serum Hcy levels in PCOS [48] [62] . In a prospective cohort study, the combination of ethinyl estradiol/drospirenone (EE-DRSP) and spironolactone treatment were given to lean and glucose tolerant patients with PCOS for 6 months, improved androgen excess but the combination increased Hcy level and CRP level [63] . Similarly, oral contraceptives containing 0.03 mg ethinyl estradiol and 0.15 mg desogestrel for 6 months had significantly decreased Hcy level in non-obese normoandrogenic PCOS patients [61] . Furthermore, oral contraceptives containing 35 µg ethinyl estradiol and 2 mg cyproterone acetate had resulted in rapid decrease in Hcy level in non-smoking PCOS women [64] [65] [66] , whereas Hcy level remains high in the smokers. It has also been studied that Hcy levels decreased after regular exercises for 6 months [67] and also have shown to decrease 3 months after ovarian surgery [68] .

Highlights

  • Transmission of PCOS traits in mice occurs via an altered DNA methylation landscape
  • Metabolic- and inflammatory-related pathways are dysregulated in models of PCOS
  • Common hypomethylation signatures occur in a mouse model of PCOS and in humans
  • Identification of a novel epigenetic-based therapeutic strategy for PCOS

Summary

Polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) is the most common reproductive and metabolic disorder affecting women of reproductive age. PCOS has a strong heritable component, but its pathogenesis has been unclear. Here, we performed RNA sequencing and genome-wide DNA methylation profiling of ovarian tissue from control and third-generation PCOS-like mice.

We found that DNA hypomethylation regulates key genes associated with PCOS and that several of the differentially methylated genes are also altered in blood samples from women with PCOS compared with healthy controls. Based on this insight, we treated the PCOS mouse model with the methyl group donor S-adenosylmethionine and found that it corrected their transcriptomic, neuroendocrine, and metabolic defects.

These findings show that the transmission of PCOS traits to future generations occurs via an altered landscape of DNA methylation and propose methylome markers as a possible diagnostic landmark for the condition, while also identifying potential candidates for epigenetic-based therapy.

Discussion

We speculate that a global loss of DNA methylation, particularly in promoter-TSS and upstream-promoters, could be responsible for genomic instability in the disease condition. Consistently, a genome-wide DNA methylation study on umbilical cord blood reports a prevalence of hypomethylation in women with PCOS compared with unaffected women (Lambertini et al., 2017). As genomic instability is highly correlated with DNA damage, excessive DNA demethylation could be thus associated with impaired DNA damage repair. This is in line with many reports describing a strong association between PCOS and malignancies, such as ovarian and endometrial cancer (Escobar-Morreale, 2018), and suggest that a higher predisposition to cancer detected in women with PCOS could be due to altered DNA methylation landscapes.

Remarkably, we report that several of the differentially methylated genes identified in ovarian tissues of PCOS mice of the third generation are also altered in blood samples from women with PCOS and from daughters of women with PCOS compared with healthy women. Six genes associated with DNA demethylation (TET1), axon guidance (ROBO-1), inhibition of cell proliferation (CDKN1A), inflammation (HDC), and insulin signaling (IGFBPL1IRS4) are hypomethylated in women with PCOS as compared with controls, and three genes (ROBO-1HDC, and IGFBPL1) are also hypomethylated in daughters diagnosed with PCOS.

Here, we examined the therapeutic potential of SAM, a known natural agent causing methylation of several genes (Chik et al., 2014). To our knowledge, this is the first direct evidence for the potential therapeutic effect of SAM in a preclinical model of PCOS. Our investigation showed that SAM treatment can rescue the major PCOS reproductive neuroendocrine and metabolic alterations of PAMH F3 mice, thus highlighting the therapeutic potential of methylating agents as promising epigenetic therapies aimed at treating women with PCOS. We provide evidence that the methylating agent restores the aberrant expression of most inflammatory genes investigated in the ovaries as well as in metabolic tissues of PAMH F3 adult mice. Numerous studies show a causal link between low-grade inflammation and metabolic diseases, including T2D (Reilly and Saltiel, 2017). Moreover, the degree of inflammation correlates well with the severity of insulin resistance, T2D, and hyperandrogenism related to PCOS (González et al., 2006Zhao et al., 2015).

Based on our findings we can speculate that the trigger for tissue inflammations could emanate from altered DNA methylation landscapes, which can be corrected by the SAM.

Taken together, this study points to AMH excess during gestation as a detrimental factor leading to the transgenerational transmission of PCOS cardinal neuroendocrine, reproductive, and metabolic alterations and shed lights into the epigenetic modifications underlying the susceptibility of the disease while pointing to novel diagnostic tools and epigenetic-based therapeutic avenues to treat the disease.

Today, a PCOS diagnosis is based on having two of three characteristic features. The first is high levels of male sex hormones like testosterone, which can cause acne, excess hair on the face and body and thinning head hair. The second is irregular or no periods, which occur because eggs often haven’t developed properly in the ovaries. This prevents their regular monthly release in the form of ovulation, meaning that it can take longer to become pregnant. The third is the presence of 20 or more “cysts” on either ovary, which are now understood to be eggs that are stuck in an immature state, rather than actual cysts.

In addition to these key features, around 50 to 70 per cent of individuals with PCOS develop resistance to insulin, which can lead to higher levels of this hormone, type 2 diabetes, weight gain, high blood pressure and heart disease. PCOS also increases the risk of endometrial and pancreatic cancer, and can cause anxiety, depression and reduced sex drive in some people.

The psychological effects may be directly caused by hormonal imbalances. Alternatively, they might arise because “if you’re a teenager, when PCOS symptoms emerge, and you’re gaining weight rapidly, you have significant acne, your periods are all over the place and you have body hair where you don’t want it, it can have a really significant impact on your self-esteem”, says Helena Teede at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia.

Finally, people with PCOS who become pregnant are more likely to have miscarriages or complications like gestational diabetes or preterm birth.

PCOS affects around 5 to 18 per cent of cis women and up to 58 per cent of trans men, although the reason why this latter figure is higher has yet to be pinned down. Despite being relatively common, it has long been one of the most neglected health conditions, says Teede. “It’s twice as common as diabetes but gets less than a hundredth of the funding,” she says. Elisabet Stener-Victorin at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden tells a similar story. “Up until about 10 years ago, I would never put ‘PCOS’ in the title of my research grant applications because it really dragged down my chances of getting funding,” she says.

Part of the problem is that it is “everybody’s business and nobody’s business”, says Teede. The many symptoms of PCOS, which vary widely between individuals, means it is managed by a range of health professionals: endocrinologists, gynaecologists, reproductive specialists, dermatologists, primary care doctors, dieticians and so on. For a long time, no one was sure who should be steering the ship and each speciality treated PCOS differently, which “constantly created confusing messages”, says Teede.

To rectify this, Teede led the development of the first international, evidence-based guidelines for PCOS, which were published in 2018. They were based on consultations with more than 3000 health professionals and people with the condition from 71 countries. 

The guidelines explain how to diagnose PCOS and manage it using existing treatments. Diet and exercise interventions are recommended to begin with, since these have been shown to simultaneously improve the metabolic, reproductive and psychological features of the condition. This is because diet and exercise can assist weight loss and improve blood sugar control, which, in turn, reduce insulin and testosterone levels.

Stener-Victorin and her colleagues, found that women in Sweden were five times as likely to be diagnosed with PCOS if their mother has the condition. No single gene has been found to be responsible for PCOS, but certain patterns of genes involved in testosterone production, ovarian function and metabolism appear to be linked with the condition. Still, these genetic variations don’t tell the whole story of how PCOS is passed down generations.

Growing evidence suggests PCOS-related hormonal imbalances during pregnancy can also have an effect on the fetus. “In a woman with PCOS, you have both the genetic factors and the in utero environment,” says Stener-Victorin. “I think it’s likely that you may carry some susceptibility genes and then you have an in utero environment that triggers its onset.” Two hormones suspected to be involved in this in utero effect are testosterone and anti-Müllerian hormone (AMH), both of which tend to be elevated in those with PCOS.

Stener-Victorin and her colleagues have found that injecting excess amounts of a form of testosterone into pregnant female mice caused their female offspring to develop many of the hallmarks of human PCOS, including irregular cycles, and greater fat mass and body weight. Similarly, when Giacobini’s team injected excess AMH into pregnant female mice, their female offspring had irregular cycles, the appearance of “polycystic” ovaries, elevated testosterone, insulin resistance, higher body weight and greater fat mass. “We now have an animal model that not only recapitulates the reproductive aspects of PCOS, but also the metabolic component seen in many women,” says Giacobini. “So, we can use these animals to really investigate the disease and design new treatment options.”

Most recently, his team discovered that the daughter mice with PCOS-like symptoms, whose mothers were injected with excess AMH during pregnancy, had altered expression of several genes involved in inflammation. This has led Giacobini to believe that PCOS is actually an inflammatory condition. His team found increased expression of inflammatory genes in the brain, ovaries, liver and fat of the mice, which he says may explain why these organs are all affected by the condition (see “Not just ovaries”, pictured above). This fits with emerging evidence of a link between inflammation and PCOS in people. A 2021 analysis led by Saad Amer at the University of Nottingham, UK, for instance, found that women with PCOS had significantly higher levels of an inflammatory marker called C-reactive protein compared with those without the condition.

Could these findings lead to new treatments? Giacobini’s team has spent the past few years developing drugs to lower AMH levels. The researchers are about to test these in mice, before hopefully progressing to human trials. “But we need to be very cautious because there are AMH receptors in different parts of the brain and a range of organs,” he says. “We cannot predict yet whether such treatment may trigger undesirable side effects until we fully comprehend the role of AMH in all those organs.” Interestingly, AMH declines with age, which may explain why some with PCOS who were unable to conceive naturally in their 20s and 30s are able to do so in their 40s, when their AMH levels fall into the normal fertility range, says Giacobini. This delayed fertility window could also be the reason why those with PCOS reach menopause four years later than average.

Another treatment option may be drugs that correct the altered expression of inflammatory and other genes implicated in PCOS, says Giacobini. Last year, his team showed that PCOS-like symptoms could be reversed in female mice by giving them a drug called S-adenosylmethionine that corrected the altered gene expressions. This drug couldn’t be safely given to people because it affects too many other genes, but it may be possible to develop more tailored treatments in the future, says Giacobini.

Teede says these approaches are worth pursuing, but cautions against extrapolating too far from animal studies. “PCOS is not caused by one mechanism, it’s multiple mechanisms that add up together,” she says. “If you’ve got an animal model that uses one mechanism to induce a PCOS-like status, you might be able to reverse that one mechanism, but treating a complex multifactorial condition in humans is harder.”

Misleading moniker

Is it time to rename polycystic ovary syndrome? There is a growing push to do so since it is now recognised as a whole-body condition, people can be diagnosed with it even if they don’t have “polycystic” ovaries and we now know that the “cysts” are undeveloped eggs, not actual cysts.

“We desperately need a name change,” says Helena Teede at Monash University in Melbourne, Australia. “The name should reflect what it actually is. Having a name around the ovaries misses the diversity of the condition.”

Teede and her colleagues are consulting health professionals and people with the condition to agree on a new name – the most preferred one at this stage is “reproductive metabolic syndrome”.

They hope to formalise this name change in the middle of this year when they release an updated version of the international guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of the condition.

Get notified about new editions

Subscribe to the Sunday Supplement

Connecting women, science and spirit, the Gynelogic Sunday Supplement delivers a bi-monthly dose of  news, views and reviews, as seen through my lady lens.